October 6, 2025 – Chess World in Debate
On October 5, 2025, during the exhibition match Checkmate: USA vs India in Arlington, Texas, Hikaru Nakamura defeated India’s young world champion D. Gukesh in a bullet chess game. But it was not just the win that caught attention. After his victory, Nakamura picked up Gukesh’s king and threw it into the crowd. The moment sparked widespread controversy in the chess world.
What Exactly Happened
The event was an exhibition, not a formal tournament. But viewers expected decorum. After drawing earlier games (10-minute and 5-minute), Nakamura and Gukesh played a 1-minute “bullet” decider. Nakamura checkmated Gukesh using his queen and cut off escape squares with a bishop.
Immediately after, Nakamura grabbed Gukesh’s king from the board and hurled it toward the spectators. The gesture was dramatic. Many critics felt it was disrespectful, especially because Gukesh is the reigning world champion.
Reactions from the Chess Community
Vladimir Kramnik, former world champion, was one of the loudest critics. He condemned the act as “tasteless” and “vulgar.” He said such behavior damages the image of chess.
Some others debated context. They noted that the event was organized in a show-style format, with the crowd cheering, loud reactions, and entertainment flair. The toss might have been part of the showmanship rather than personal disrespect.
Even Magnus Carlsen’s coach, Peter Heine Nielsen, came to Nakamura’s defense. He said that modern chess events often blur between sport and performance. He argued that such acts make chess “look like a sporting event” rather than just a quiet board game.
The organisers also responded. They admitted that players were asked “to have fun” and to bend conventional chess etiquette for crowd appeal. In a post, they said they “forced the players to have fun … and forego the FIDE Etiquette.”
Nakamura’s Explanation
In interviews and statements, Nakamura defended his action. He said from the start he planned to throw the king if he won. He called it a theatrical moment suited to the high drama of a bullet finish.
He also hoped fans enjoyed it, saying that chess is usually very “lonely” and that more expressive moments can energize live audiences.
However, he denied any intent to insult Gukesh. He said the gesture was not meant as disrespect.
The Bigger Picture
This incident has ignited deeper questions: How much showmanship is acceptable in chess? Where should one draw the line between dramatic entertainment and sportsmanship?
Many older fans and purists fear that aggressive theatrics erode the dignity of chess. They argue chess should remain a cerebral, respectful pursuit, even in exhibition formats. Kramnik, for example, warned against a “degradation of modern chess.”
On the other hand, proponents of innovation say events must evolve. Live audiences, fans, media, and younger viewers demand spectacle. Exhibition events, especially, may allow more leeway for dramatic gestures to attract attention.
Another point is future rivalry. This dramatic moment has set a spicy stage for future Nakamura vs Gukesh matches. Their upcoming game in Clutch Chess: Champions Showdown, scheduled for October 27-29 in St. Louis, is now under extra spotlight.
The Indian Express
Leave a Reply